What is Tonalism? Part I

In the decade following the Civil War, America came to terms with its great loss–both of a generation of young men, and the feeling of high spirited nationalistic pride and belief in itself as the chosen land and the chosen people of God’s creation. The societal underpinnings of religious faith were likewise shaken. The operatic creations of Hudson River School artists like Church, Cole, Bierstadt and Moran seemed completely out of touch with a more subdued and melancholy national zeitgeist. A quiet more reflective art was more appropriate to the public mood.

As a result, by the 1880’s nothing short of a revolution had occurred in American landscape painting. The large panoramic views and detailed foregrounds of the Hudson River School were replaced by the suggestive, atmospheric and intimate landscapes of the Tonalist artists. The first generation of Tonalist artists like George Inness had begun painting in the prevalent Hudson River School style at the beginning of their careers, but pioneered a new poetic, spiritual, and personal style of landscape painting. These evocative landscapes struck an elegiac chord, often depicting transitional times of day and autumnal seasons.

Onness Georgia Sunset
Georgia Sunset- George Inness
Screen Shot 2014-09-22 at 10.52.35 AM
Autumn Montclair George Inness

The first generation of Tonalist artists, born between 1840 and 1865, were shaped by American experience and culture. In the writings of Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau, Americans found a different way of responding to nature and a more mystical spirituality. No two authors were more widely read and had a greater influence on late 19th century American thought and culture–an influence that lasts to this day.

Eaton Sunset Pines
Sunset Pines-Charles Warren Eaton

 

Screen Shot 2019-06-03 at 10.37.15 AM
Autumn Twilight- Charles Warren Eaton
Screen Shot 2019-06-03 at 10.37.33 AM
Poplars-Charles Warren Eaton

Emerson (1803-1882) first set forth his philosophy of Transcendentalism in the 1836 essay Nature. Emerson espoused that nature was an emblem or symbol, and its relevance lay in the insights it provided into the human mind and spirit. As a mentor and friend to Thoreau, Emerson asked the young Thoreau “do you keep a journal?”, an inquiry which spurred the perhaps most prolific journal writer in American literature.

- Murphy with boat 2
J. Francis Murphy

Thoreau (1817-1862) although a fellow Transcendentalist, was cut from a very different cloth. Emerson was full of Romantic subjectivity, using brilliantly insightful generalizations and intuitive leaps about the realm of the spirit. Thoreau was a wanderer, a nature writer, and a keen almost obsessive observer of the natural world. As a result, his more empirical approach was the platform from which he drew insights into the human soul. For Thoreau, nature was reality, important for its own sake as well as for symbolic purposes. But for both Emerson and Thoreau, the meeting of the material and the spiritual world in a transcendent experience was the goal and a possibility for every human being.

Birge Harrison nocturne
Birge Harrison

Nature was no longer simply the Hudson River School’s symbol or evidence of God’s presence in the world, but instead was itself the conduit through which this transcendent state might occur. For Thoreau particularly, the act of perception of Nature was the first step toward a “mystical unity of the observer and the observed”.

Screen Shot 2019-06-03 at 10.53.52 AM
Birge Harrison

Emerson lectured widely in his later years and his ideas began to catch the public imagination especially after the Civil War. Although Thoreau died in 1862, his work was not widely read in America until the 1880s. His combination of transcendental philosophy, non-sectarian spiritualism, and dedication to the idea of correspondence between man and nature, made him a perfect prophet for the Tonalist revolution. His nature descriptions were praised by the subsequent Tonalist generation of artists. Dwight Tryon called Thoreau “the best landscape word painter”.

Today, the Tonalist style of landscape painting has reemerged as a contemporary movement. The philosophical and spiritual underpinnings of the original Tonalist movement, and its emphasis on a personal relationship with nature, makes this style particularly appealing to the contemporary landscape painter and an apt reflection of our times. The landmark publication of David Cleveland’s History of American Tonalism in 2010 introduced a whole new generation of artists and collectors to the Tonalist aesthetic. The growing interest in this style of painting is reflected in the recent formation of the American Tonalist Society and its inaugural exhibition at the historic Salmagundi Club in New York, an institution with deep ties to the original Tonalist movement.

Pineywoods Evening 1212 72 dpi
Pineywoods Evening-Deborah Paris

In Part II of this post, we’ll take a look at the contemporary landscape painters who have adopted the Tonalist aesthetic and how their works both reflect the historic roots of Tonalism and represent a leading edge of contemporary landscape painting.

P.S. Our six week online class Painting the Luminous Landscape is an introduction to the Tonalist style and to indirect painting techniques. It starts June 21st. Join us!

 

6 thoughts on “What is Tonalism? Part I”

  1. Beautifully written and presented article on one of my favorite topics Deborah.
    I do have a question and might be completely wrong about this , but I understand most of the leading American
    landscape painters had the luxury of studying in Europe and I see a remarkable influence of Barbizon school
    Such as Leon Germaine Pelouse, Corot etc . Am I missing something? It doesn’t exclude many other factors, economic , social etc. Thanks

    1. Thanks John. I am glad you enjoyed it. Yes, great question! The first generation of Tonalist painters like Inness (in his earlier Tonalist works), Hunt and LaFarge were most definitely influenced by the Barbizon style (Hunt in particular). However, it is interesting that Inness told his son that the European painter who had most influenced him was Constable. Constable of course was a huge influence on French landscape painting, his work having been seen in the Paris Salon by the young artists who would form the Barbizon school. But I digress. 🙂

      However, by the time the later generation of Tonalist artists developed around the 1880s, the Barbizon style was considered old fashioned, and the European influences that the second generation received had more to do with Whistlerian tonal aestheticism and Japanese art through him. Cleveland makes this point repeatedly and even quotes John LaFarge as saying in a 1908 lecture that the American painters “had built a form of painting as different as it could possibly be…” from the Barbizon school. It is also interesting to note that the Barbizon label was repeatedly used in the 20th c. to denigrate the Tonalist artists as being derivitive. Unfortunately Hunt had around 1900 used the term “American Barbizon” as a sort of marketing ploy to describe Old Lyme. Cleveland’s opinion is that this stuck and contributed to the “misidentification of Tonalism with Barbizon.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s